Diverting so many IDF units to the West Bank was a key factor in allowing the Oct. 7 attack to succeed. They left the Gaza border virtually undefended, when even a small force, if on duty, could have repelled the invaders that day.
I think calling an end to the war is essential - but until Hamas is removed, I don’t see how Israel can withdraw from the Philadelphia Corridor or even the Netzarim Corridor. And the problem of food distribution with UNRWA needs to be better resolved.
Israel can certainly declare victory and go home. But Hamas will do the same. Which "declaration" will serve Israel's requirements best? How will both declarations be received by Israerl's friends and enemies?
I think at this point, after defeating Hezbollah, effectively defeating Iran, I don't think that Hamas claiming victory over a devastated Gaza Strip will hold much weight. Would it have been better if they had collapsed totally, yes, but after 631 days, this is enough.
I humbly say I agree with every word and thank you for saying it.
Diverting so many IDF units to the West Bank was a key factor in allowing the Oct. 7 attack to succeed. They left the Gaza border virtually undefended, when even a small force, if on duty, could have repelled the invaders that day.
Thank you for this, Marc. I have shared it on Facebook and also with friends in my community who are not on FB.
I think calling an end to the war is essential - but until Hamas is removed, I don’t see how Israel can withdraw from the Philadelphia Corridor or even the Netzarim Corridor. And the problem of food distribution with UNRWA needs to be better resolved.
Israel can certainly declare victory and go home. But Hamas will do the same. Which "declaration" will serve Israel's requirements best? How will both declarations be received by Israerl's friends and enemies?
I think at this point, after defeating Hezbollah, effectively defeating Iran, I don't think that Hamas claiming victory over a devastated Gaza Strip will hold much weight. Would it have been better if they had collapsed totally, yes, but after 631 days, this is enough.